Home | Yahoo Answers

Who is the most underrated and overrated QB in the NFL?

Underrated: Tyrod Taylor, Bills

Buffalo might have found a QB that can last for more than 2 seasons. Considering some of his best offensive players have been injured for part of the season (Watkins, Harvin, McCoy, Williams) he makes the Bills a fringe playoff team.

Overrated: Russell Wilson, Seahawks

He is not...

show more

Underrated: Tyrod Taylor, Bills

Buffalo might have found a QB that can last for more than 2 seasons. Considering some of his best offensive players have been injured for part of the season (Watkins, Harvin, McCoy, Williams) he makes the Bills a fringe playoff team.

Overrated: Russell Wilson, Seahawks

He is not bad but he is not a player that can carry a team. The team (mainly the defense) has carried him for the last 2 Super Bowl bound seasons. Now the defense has been pretty inconsistent and thus Seattle offense has struggled to put up TDs (even with the Graham trade). But Seahawk fans at least he is better than Mark Sanchez when the Jets defense carried the team to the AFC championship game in 09 and 10.



Who do you think is the most underrated and overrated QB in the NFL?