VW could use bank-style clawback of CEO pay
By Olaf Storbeck and Antony Currie
The authors are Reuters Breakingviews columnists. The opinions expressed are their own.
Martin Winterkorns resignation as Volkswagenschief executive clears the way for sweeping changes at Europes largest carmaker. VW doesnt just need to explain how 482,000 of its U.S. diesel passenger vehicles were rigged to cheat on emissions tests with the software also installed in 11 million cars globally. It also needs to reform its culture and radically simplify an overly complex structure. A good place to start would be to overhaul executive compensation.
Winterkorn took home 15.9 million euros ($17.8 million) last year, not including pension benefits. That made him one of Germanys highest-paid bosses. Former Chairman Ferdinand Piech, who resigned in April, was the countrys best-remunerated chairman in 2014, with 1.5 million euros.
Bonuses of 68 million euros, mostly in cash, accounted for some 90 percent of Winterkorns pay between 2009 and 2014, the period when Volkswagen was manipulating U.S. emission tests. During most of that time, he was not only the CEO of the entire company but also boss of the VW passenger car brand which sold the bulk of the doctored cars. He was also directly responsible for the companys research and development operations.
The company on Tuesday set aside 6.5 billion euros just to cover the potential costs of recalling and fixing the affected cars. That equates to roughly 60 percent of the net income Volkswagen is expected to earn this year, according to Thomson Reuters data.
That could be just the start, though. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency could in theory hit VW with a bill as high as $18 billion. In addition, the companys market value has plunged by some 22 billion euros and it may lose sales and face other legal claims as a result of the fiasco.
Ideally, Winterkorn should shoulder his share of the financial pain. That would involve his employer clawing back some or all of his bonuses, akin to what banks have promised to do in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis. For now, it looks like Volkswagens compensation program lacks any mechanism to do that. The companys board could, of course, apply moral pressure. And it should certainly consider a clawback policy for future top executives. That would send a strong message to prospective managers, customers and regulators alike.